[Attaguy]

Which celebs would you cast in the following catfight scenario? And who wins?

A how single gal, who has no shortage of dates, gets off on having guys fight over her and then rewarding the winner. She provokes a fight between her newest guy and her on and off again boyfriend. The new guy takes the bait  and gets beaten so badly that he ends up in the hospital. The new guy’s big sister finds out who caused her kid brother’s injuries.. Sis tracks down “that bitch” and confronts her at her home. A wild back and forth catfight ensues and ends with one of them laying unconscious on the floor.

Thanks for your attention.

[sinclairfan]

The "secret sauce" to this one is to make the brother-sister actors be a real life brother-sister pair.

Say, Jake Gyllenhaal and Maggie Gyllenhaal.

So, make Maggie G. the avenging sister.  She's never liked Blake Lively, and beats the crap out of her after Blake makes Jake G. and Matthew Mcgonaghy fight.

[puyol174]

Love this idea.

For me I would want the girl who likes to get the guys to fight over her to be shorter and less powerful looking than her opponent. She would be terrified when the other girl shows up with her brother at her boyfriend's house. BUUUUT she would soon find out that the big girl who came for vengeance had a really low pain threshold and that being a loser ran in the family. She would be embarrassed and reduced to tears as the bad girl stripped her and threw her out.

I'd go Lucy Hale beating Troian Bellisario, Leighton Meester beating Taylor Momsen or Sarah Michelle Gellar getting the better of Katherine Heigl.

[VAKris]

The "secret sauce" to this one is to make the brother-sister actors be a real life brother-sister pair.

Say, Jake Gyllenhaal and Maggie Gyllenhaal.

So, make Maggie G. the avenging sister.  She's never liked Blake Lively, and beats the crap out of her after Blake makes Jake G. and Matthew Mcgonaghy fight.

I agree with Sinclairfan, the secret of this puzzle is the brother/sister aspect.   So I am going to my "way back machine" for the following.   Lisa Whelchel (Blair on "Facts of Life") is having her way getting boys to fight over her.   Phillip McKeon ("Alice") is taken down for Lisa's pleasure.   Sister Nancy McKeon (Jo on "Facts of Life") helps her brother home, but then goes back to do some payback on her former co-star.   Nancy tears into Lisa, who doesn't back down, and leaves her a mess on the floor after a tough fight.