Our catfights are staged to a point in that we give the girls a general scenario, usually based on a members request. We give the the girls the bullet points the member wants to see and once they have the rough outline, we roll the camera and let them go for it so the honest answer, in part yes, in part no.
Requests are more specific in f-f-fights.com and the photo sets we are asked to produce for memebrs have to be a higher quality than those we shoot for femmefight (so femmefight we shoot at the same time as the video is taking place - and as clothing often gets destroyed, it's the only way we can get pics and vids at the same time) whereas on f-f-fights, the pic stes are done seprate to the vid and are therefore stage managed for effectiveness.
Hope that answers it.
cheers