[zaq9]

Who wins this catfight and how?

Left Nicole 5'11 58 Kg
Right Jennifer 5'5 59 kg

[wheelman]

Nicole has always struck me as one of those tall lanky ladies that lack the coordination and athleticism to be able to use their height/reach to their advantage in a physical confrontation.  A tough athletic gal like JLo would annihilate her in a catfight. 

[Ginny38]

I DOUBT either weight is accurate. (Too heavy for the slender Kidman, too light for the stocky, Lopez)

Not that weight should be a deciding metric in a fight, but it does help in deciding who might win if you imagine a stand-up vs an on-the-ground style fight happening.

Still, I voted so maybe the result will reflect opinions contrary to mine. Its an interesting matchup and one I would like to see in real life, if only to see if my opinion of a winner had any validity.

 

[zaq9]

Jlo taking the lead so far....

[zaq9]

I DOUBT either weight is accurate. (Too heavy for the slender Kidman, too light for the stocky, Lopez)

Not that weight should be a deciding metric in a fight, but it does help in deciding who might win if you imagine a stand-up vs an on-the-ground style fight happening.

Still, I voted so maybe the result will reflect opinions contrary to mine. Its an interesting matchup and one I would like to see in real life, if only to see if my opinion of a winner had any validity.

 

I looked up the stats on the internet .
Who do you thinks wins a stand up kickboxing match?

[Firefly]

I see Nicole trying to use her longer reach to keep the stronger more athletic Lopez at bay, but once Lopez gets inside its over fairly quickly.

[Ginny38]

Based upon rudimentary Internet search criteria, it would seem Bjr99 has more or less given accurate numbers for Ms. Lopez. And while my "eyeball" test says Ms. Kidman-Urban is certainly less "weighty" than J-Lo, her slender build and taller height may give the illusion of a lesser weight. So I withdraw my contention (graciously!)

Anyone who tries to find "accurate" weights for celebrities is going to sooner or later, end up banging their heads against a wall (or other immovable object) for none of them will allow accurate numbers to be revealed once they pass the point in their careers where they are able to regain control of information.

Jen just LOOKS heavier, stronger, more solidly constructed - by about 10 pounds. (My goodness, her derriere alone probably weighs more than Kidman did in her prime!)
Yet, being proved wrong- won't effect my vote for Lopez for being the one I see winning this fight!

Jen Lopez (1)   138
Jen Lopez (2)   130 (no source given)
Jen Lopez (3)   130         "
Jen Lopez (4)   130         "


Nic Kidman (1)   120
Nic Kidman (2)   128
Nic Kidman (3)   128(same source? Does it even matter?)
Nic Kidman (4)   122         unsourced

[Mr. Bear]

Poll has Nicole losing, Reality may have Nicole losing, but fantasy in this dudes mind has Nicole ruling that ass in many ways after a long back and forth battle.

[Ginny38]

...in this dudes mind has Nicole ruling that ass...

In his usual succinct style, Mr. Bear goes straight to the bottom  line.

[zaq9]

Can anyone write a short story of how it goes down? Make your own scenario/rules

[Mr. Bear]

HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

Yes Ginny...yes I did.

 

PS. Love the Gif!