[catfightlover67]

What a fantasy catfight this would be.......Ashley and Amanda in long sexy gowns in an all out sexy catfight! I would pick Ashley Tisdale!  The look on her face says MEOWWWWWWWW

[stoneyrasta]

i like ashley too, but in a fight amanda's size advantage would be too much. ashley is 5'3" 115 lbs and amanda is 5'8" 130 lbs. i see them as being equal in fighting skills so amanda wins because of her superior size.  

[djcrash]

Would pick Amanda.

[de Trixah]

Amanda is too big for little Ashley.

[suzuran]

In a NHB-Catfight everything can happen.
And so even smaller Ashley could beat Amanda.
But beside who win´s, tha fight would be GREAT!!!

[Vassago]

Ashley Tisdale wins this catfight!