This question gets posed a lot on the various catfight messageboards and the responses are usually similar. I'd bet that if you asked 100 catfight fans what they want to see in a video, you'd get 100 different answers. This market involves fantasy, and each of us has a somewhat different one. Just take "messy wrestling." Some guys want mud, others oil, others pudding, others cole slaw, others syrup. Then what flavor? Maple, rasberry or chocolate? In other words, this market is fragmented to the max. Frankly, I don't see how any company can make a profit. Not only is the market fragmented, it's fairly small, there are a lot of competitors, and the amount of free stuff that one can access (either legally or otherwise) all add up red ink on the bottom line. At least that's what I gather.
I think that's why you see so many companies start up, produce 5 or 6 videos, but no more -- ever. It seemed like a good idea at the time. Kind of like the "entrepreneur" who goes away on a holiday weekend in summer and notices that the local cafes are all busy; so he buys one figuring that he's going to make a killing. Then Fall and Winter hit and he experiences 6 months of no customers. Then his cafe, like so many producers disappear in the mist.
I believe that the O-man is right, we should at least purchase the stuff we want to see, so these producers have some kind of a fighting chance to survive.