Lots of good suggestions and lots of support for many women. Looks like Faye has been underrepresented here in fights from the wide variety of women people would like to see her fight.
The voting ended up in a tie for who should fight her: Raquel Welch, Marina Sirtis, and Angie Dickenson with 39 votes.
Ursula Andress, Ann-Margret, Jane Fonda, and Sharon Stone were right behind with 38 votes.
Alice Krige and Claudia Cardinale had support, finishing with 37 votes.
The other one with over 30 votes was Sylva Koscina with 35 votes.
Since there is a tie of the top three I like eagleton's earlier suggest of a four way fight. Except it won't be Fay, Claudia Cardinale, Brigitte Bardot, and Raquel Welch. Instead it will be Marina Sirtis for Claudia and Angie DIckenson for Brigitte.
I am thinking of writing this story of all four women getting into it in a bar. Then, borrowing from Kimval's suggestion the fight would move out into the alley where they can fight without interference. How do others feel about this?