[Mr. Drake]

The Wrestling Wars and Netflix Vs Amazon series will return soon (I'm having more fun with this series). But for now this is the Battle of the TV Female Leads! We'll be looking at some of the best and most infamous Female led TV shows and pitting their female heroine or anti-heroine actresses into a fight against one another! Today we're going to look at two shows, which are, well the same! Or not quite the same, as the reboot of Charmed features a different cast of characters from the original, but retains the basic premise. Curious to see what people think of this match-up. This week it's Charmed's Shannon Doherty Vs Charmed's (2018) Madeleine Mantock! I know these are both ensemble shows, with three women usually as the leads, but I picked these two since they're playing similar characters, both the eldest sister, and are often listed first on the cast list. Funny that the reboot aired 20 years after the original first aired, same month too! These battles take place at the show's debut so we'll be looking back into the past for our references to how they were then! (We'll use their recent height and weight though because I have no idea how I'd find that for their debut season years). Also if anybody has any ideas/suggestions for a third category (To break ties) I'd love to hear it! Please let me know in the comments or with a message.

Prue Halliwell  (Charmed) - Shannon Doherty
Show Premier Date: October 1998
Doherty's Age Then: 27
Height: 5'4
Weight: 128 lbs



(Shannon Doherty on the left)

Macy Vaughn (Charmed 2018) - Madeleine Mantock
Show Premier Date: October 2018
Mantock's Age Then: 28
Height: 5'8
Weight: 126 lbs



(Madeleine Mantock on the left)

[de Trixah]

Bigger and presumably Macy/Madelaine would win.

[fleuger99]

New Charmed sucks, along with new Magnum PI.

[JT Edson]

In her prime Shannon Doherty would cave this girl in no time.

[Mr. Drake]

And..... Prue Halliwell aka Shannon Doherty wins! This started off pretty close in the catfight portion of the poll, but slowly, then very rapidly, Shannon pulled away! Madeleine actually had the lead in the catfight category for a small bit of time, but couldn't overcome Shannon's huge comeback victory. Shannon won the cat-fight category by 9 votes, 25 to 16, not a huge margin. Doherty also won the hotness category, leading the entire way through and winning by a larger margin of 17 votes, 27 to 10. I had a feeling Shannon would win the hotness category by a fair margin (No disrespect of course to the beautiful Madeleine Mantock) but I really had no idea who'd win the catfight category, the size difference between them leading me to believe Mantock might win. But I can easily see the argument for either women winning that category! But in the end, Shannon Doherty was just to much for Mantock, winning both categories to become this editions winner! Thanks for voting everyone!

Then and Now

Shannon Doherty Then (1998 - Age:27)


Shannon Doherty Now (2020 - Age:49)


Still a beauty!