I find scripted matches to be waaay better than real matches. Rarely have I ever seen a real fight come even close to a well done scripted fight.
Real fights are usually even, and if one girl gets the advantage, it ends soon enough. A scripted fight can be a squash match, where the weaker girl gets worked over slowly and intensely. She has to be an expert at selling the pain being dealt to her. That is HUGE. The dominate girl has to sell the blows. Scripted matches with fake blows are HORRIBLE. How to sell a punch to the face? Angle it away from the camera so it's out of view. Then you can throw a real punch, "connect", and then the receiving girl can sell the blow. That's what matters. Use the camera angles to disguise the fake blows, and let the selling do all the work.
Scripted matches' hair pulling is waaay better than in real life. In a scripted match, hair pulling is more dominate, with the receiving girl helpless, able to do nothing but scream in pain, suffering the hair pull, her hands holding her own head in agony. The dominate girl yanks the weaker girl off the floor by her hair. EVERY time. She drags her around the room, bent over, by her hair. Total domination.
When the beatings are over, the dominate girl stands over her victim, who is lying in a heap on the floor and plants her bare foot right over her face. Total domination.
Scripted matches are insanely sexy when done right. Nudity or sex is not required. Simple bra & panties are beyond sexy, especially if they are white. A slower, intimate fight, where the dominate girl is more interested in hurting her opponent than ending the fight in victory is off scale in appeal! Pro wrestling squash matches are a real good template for a scripted catfight. They get it.
Look at the beating Mimi Hagiwara takes in this match:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3uE-0RzGjw&t=400sFrom 5:50 to 9:15 she is absolutely brutalized by her opponents. Relentless hair pulling, arm twisting, biting, etc. THIS is how a scripted catfight should look. Few if any producers have taken the type of intensity shown in this fight and translated it into an apartment wrestling catfight. Whoever does this will be a HUGE winner.
I hope you give it a try. Good luck!