Battle of the Female TV Leads! No. 15 Scream Queens Vs Hart of Dixie

Mr. Drake · « **on:** June 05, 2020, 12:42:21 PM »

The Wrestling Wars and Netflix Vs Amazon series will return eventually (I'm having more fun with this series). But for now this is the Battle of the TV Female Leads! We'll be looking at some of the best and most infamous Female led TV shows and pitting their female heroine or anti-heroine actresses into a fight against one another! Today we're going to look at two shows with very little to nothing in common. Both are technically comedies but I was surprised Hart of Dixie was listed as a comedy-drama as I thought it was only a drama. So we've got Scream Queens Horror/Comedy against Hart of Dixie's Drama/Comedy. This is another match-up where I really don't know who will win, as both girls are often portrayed as jobbers around here on the forum. So I think it'll be interesting to see how this turns out, as both girls are very attractive and closely sized. This week it's Scream Queen's Emma Roberts Vs Hart of Dixie's Rachel Bilson! These battles take place at the show's debut so we'll be looking back into the past for our references to how they were then! (We'll use their recent height and weight though because I have no idea how I'd find that for their debut season years). Also if anybody has any ideas/suggestions for a third category (To break ties) I'd love to hear it! Please let me know in the comments or with a message.

Quick edit, I've just learned while finding photos for this poll that apparently Bilson and Roberts have some former beef! So that adds some intrigue and fire to the matchup!

Chanel Oberlin (Scream Queens) - Emma Roberts
Show Premier Date: September 2015
Roberts' Age Then: 24
Height: 5'2
Weight: 97 lbs
{alt}

Zoe Hart (Hart of Dixie) - Rachel Bilson
Show Premier Date: September 2011
Bilson's Age Then: 30
Height: 5'2
Weight: 106 lbs
{alt}

Bonus Gifs

Emma Roberts
{alt}

Rachel Bilson
{alt}

walter · « **Reply #1 on:** June 05, 2020, 06:33:53 PM »

Both are HOT, won't be able to pick one. But in a catfight, advantage to Emma Roberts

Maizenblue · « **Reply #2 on:** June 05, 2020, 08:24:46 PM »

Rachel Bilson is my favorite. Think she is the best jobber. Love to see her knocked out by Emma Roberts.

jads719 · « **Reply #3 on:** June 06, 2020, 08:56:37 PM »

Roberts wins at the ages when their shows made their debuts but Bilson is hotter.

Mr. Drake · « **Reply #4 on:** June 12, 2020, 03:13:28 PM »

And..... Zoe Hart aka Rachel Bilson wins! Wow this is easily one of the closest matchups in the history of the series! And in my opinion one of, if not the best! Rachel maintained her lead on the hotness category the entire poll duration, but Emma got close to usurping her on numerous occasions. And the catfight category! These two woman traded the top spot, back and forth in a bid for dominance against each other, maybe each of them still harboring a bit of anger about that Hayden Christensen feud. But on the last day of the poll, Bilson took the lead and stuck it out, winning the catfight category by just 2 votes, 30 to 28. Rachel also won the hotness category by 6 votes, 31 to 25. Going into this match-up I had no clue who would end up victorious in either category as both girls are usually portrayed as jobbers around here and both are ridiculously hot! I really thought Emma had that catfight category in her grasp too, but Rachel made one hell of a comeback to win the entire poll, destroying poor Emma's hopes for a tie! This might be my favorite matchup, just because I'm such a fan of both girls and due to the poll being so close throughout! Thanks for voting everyone, this was another great voter turnout so thank you all . Special thanks to everyone who commented as well as I always love seeing everyone's thoughts and opinions on the match!

Then and Now
Rachel Bilson Then (2011 - Age:30)
{alt}