Sienna
Allyson
An au pair had been Marco’s idea. In hindsight, Allyson realized it was an idea that he raised on return from a trip to Sicily. And he volunteered to find and hire one. Red flags? Allyson was too busy to be suspicious. The twins were six now, crazy handfuls, and her work at the firm was twelve hour days. Sex with Marco had cooled, sure, but they were thirty-two now, with frantic lives, not lust-filled twenty-two-year-olds.
Marco’s search was short. He hired Sienna in no time at all. She was, in fact, twenty-two. From Sicily. Allyson was no less busy, but now she could not afford not to be suspicious. Marco worked from home. The twins were in school until 2 pm. And Sienna was a beautiful panther, graceful and dark, charming and saucy.
Sienna was good with the twins, Allyson had to admit, teaching them French and Italian. She was turning them into expert swimmers, too, constantly at their pool on the weekends, where she cut the water like a mink. Was it only Allyson who noticed her gradual transition from lessons in a modest one-piece to a barely-there bikini? Marco feigned indifference. It was California, not Church. Let her wear what she wants.
Allyson was not indifferent. Every move Sienna made reminded her of wet, filthy sex.
She began to come home unannounced and randomly during school hours. Most nights, she aggressively initiated sex with Marco, on the alert for Sienna’s scent on him, for any sign that he was sexually spent, to put her scent on him.
There was no evidence of impropriety. Her unannounced visits found Marco in his office, Sienna in her room or out at errands. Instead of her suspicions abating, however, they grew as weeks passed. They covered their tracks well, Marco and Sienna, she thought. It ate at her.
“I hear you, you know,” Sienna said to Allyson, as they were alone in the kitchen one night, Marco reading the twins to sleep. “You and Marco, when you make love.” Sienna had helped herself to the open bottle of wine, to Allyson’s annoyance. She sipped her glass now, her midriff bare and pushed against the center island. Allyson’s eyes slipped to Sienna’s breasts, large and full for such a slender frame. Perfect for Marco to nest his cock between. “I don’t say this to embarrass,” Sienna added.
“Why would I be embarrassed about fucking my husband?” Allyson’s voice was sharp. Too much wine, she thought. Were Sienna’s eyes on her breasts now? She arched her back, just a little.
“When you do - fuck him - you sound . . . angry,” Sienna said.
Allyson put her glass down with a sharp clink on the marble countertop.
“You are out of line, Sienna,” she said.
“The question is, why are you angry?” Sienna said. She arched her back too. Her nipples were stiff beneath her thin half-top. Allyson found herself picturing them. Were they as dark as Sienna’s eyes? She ignored Sienna’s question.
“I want you to wear a bra,” Allyson said. “And not that bikini. Because of the twins.”
Sienna smiled. “The twins are babies,” she said. “They don’t notice my body. Only you notice - and Marco, of course.” She stretched. “You are afraid of me,” she said. “It makes you angry.” She came around the island. “You think I am fucking him. I’m not.”
“Good,” Allyson said. She couldn’t believe this conversation; couldn’t believe this girl saw right through her. It seemed like a silly response to make, but what else could she say?
“Not yet, I mean.” Sienna said. She reached for Allyson’s blouse, felt its material, unbuttoned its top button. “I haven’t given him my pussy. Oh, I did suck his cock today, many times. I swallow all his cum, every delicious drop. He says you did that too - when you were young, like me, but no more.”
Allyson had no words for this.
“You fuck him with anger to try to keep him from me,” Sienna said. “It won’t work. If I decide to let him, he will fuck me.” She touched Allyson’s cleavage, where her blouse was open now, and ran her fingertips over the swell of her breast. “He cannot resist me. Rather than be angry, Allyson, why not . . . join us?”
“Get out,” Allyson said. Her tongue felt thick. “You’re fired.”
Sienna’s hand curved, and dipped into the cup of Allyson’s bra. Her fingers were warm, and smooth. She lifted the weight of Allyson’s breast a fraction, her thumb caressing her nipple.
“Don’t be afraid,” she whispered. “I don’t want to take him away from you. I only want to play - with both of you.” She withdrew her hand, her fingers trailing over Allyson’s stiffening nub. “So hard,” she said. “Like his cock. Is your pussy wet, Allyson?”
God, yes. Allyson was silent, but Sienna knew.
“As the saying is,” Sienna said. “You cannot beat me. Join me.”
“I can beat you,” Allyson said. Her voice was tense. She wanted Sienna’s hand on her breast again, and hated that she wanted it.
Sienna shook her head. “You are still attractive, yes,” she said. “But you are an old hat to Marco. He aches to have me. You, he fucks because you are . . . convenient. You cannot beat me in bed. Or anywhere else.”
They both heard Marco close the door to the twins’ room.
“Think of my offer,” Sienna said, and she was gone.
Later, Allyson slowly worked Marco’s cock. A long, tantric massage, with her hands, and breasts, and mouth. She took Marco deep into her throat, pushing her lips to the base of his shaft. He groaned, and pulsed, and came. There should have been a choking flood, after all she’d done, but his well was practically dry. You bastard, Allyson thought. She swung her long blonde hair to the side, and made him kiss her, to taste what she had in her mouth before she swallowed it.
“Have you ever thought of a threesome?” she asked. He said no, but his eyes contradicted the lie.
“What about with Sienna,” she said. His eyes told her the truth, once again. She boiled with fury.
In her room, Sienna listened, and smiled, as they fought. Who knew what tomorrow would bring?
By the time Sienna stretched awake in her bed the next morning, sheets cool on her naked body, Marco and the twins were gone. A text from Allyson on her phone told her this. It also told her to be out of the house by 5 pm.
“You don’t say this to my face,” Sienna said softly, to herself. She thumbed her phone.
I don’t think I will go. Last night, I decide - I want to feel his big cock inside me. You may watch, Allyson, if you like.
Sienna watched the three dots that told her a reply was coming.
He’s taken the twins to stay at his mother’s. He’ll be home at 6. I’ll be home at 5. To make sure you are gone.“Why tell me this?” Sienna said.
You say go but then tell me we three will be alone tonight. Say what you want, Allyson.
Alone in her office, Allyson held her phone tightly enough that her knuckles were white.
If I find you there when I get home, I will throw you out into the street myself.
LOL! This you cannot do. Did you consider my offer?
OUT. I mean it!Allyson’s phone rang.
“Some things should be spoken,” said Sienna. “So I tell you. Today, will enjoy your pool. I will sunbathe; topless, I think. And I will be waiting for you when you arrive home. I will give you one more chance. Then when Marco arrives after you, he will find us both waiting to fuck him, or he will find me waiting to fuck him alone.”
Allyson was breathing fast. “And where am I, in this little fantasy of yours, Sienna, where you fuck my husband alone?”
“You are my lover, or my enemy,” Sienna said. “Fuck me, or fight me. Last night, I hoped for the first. Now, truth be told, I hope for the second. I think now Marco will find it very exciting, to see you under my heel.”
With that, she was gone.
It was an eternity to 5 pm. Sienna’s words swirled in Allyson’s mind like storm clouds building.
Fuck me, or fight me.