Kelli, Crime and Punishment was a well-done chapter, as per your usual high standards. A lot of items to think about . . .
Lily is now the co-chief villain in your story, alongside Jolene. She has a clear motive for her actions against you, namely punishing you for your “past sins” as well as losing the fight to you several chapters ago. Unlike Jolene, she has friends in higher places, which could cause trouble for both you and Jake. She will be formidable to deal with. Using a henchwoman to do her dirty work is very villainous. Meanwhile, Letticia has the heart to be a great fighter, but not the skill. If she and Lily fight, I fear Lily will destroy her.
The main fight was great and you fought valiantly, but the odds were against you. Agent DuBois is well-trained as a boxer and seems to enjoy her work a bit too much. I wouldn’t mess with her in the future.
Letticia described the judge as a “fair and honorable judge”, but why does anyone (be it Lily or someone else) get to have this trial by combat event without some level of evidence of a “crime” being committed? You clearly were railroaded into a disadvantageous situation, without much opportunity to stop it. Also, despite not hearing the specified charge against you, you were sentenced to FIVE fights at the judge’s whim in the next year. Is the punishment proportional? It doesn’t seem like it. The more I think about it, the more concerned about the judge’s motives I get.
The Court seems easily corruptible by bullies trying to “avenge” made up grievances. Lily clearly conspired with Agent DuBois to do this to you. Couldn’t you accuse Lily of something, anything, get a different agent of the Court to help you and precipitate a similar trial by combat for her on demand? Couldn’t anybody do that to anyone in the Catpin universe? I know this is a fictional world, but this issue with the Court feels sinister to me. Oh, well, maybe life just isn’t fair . . .
If Rebecca does not treat you fairly, you have turned the direction of your story to a much darker course. Maybe that is your intent for future stories. Maybe after all the success your character has had in the Catpin universe, your character will now have some serious trials and tribulations to deal with. We will have to wait and see.
I look forward to your future chapters of this excellent series.