[jaybee]

So I just finished a discussion on another thread which got me thinking... Is Sarah Brook the catfight G.O.A.T (Greatest of all time)?
She's fought literally for every major company (in the states) and has an insane win/loss record. In fact I've only seen her loose one real catfight. She's done more in 6yrs than most catfighters have in multiple decades real or scripted so whether or not you enjoy her fights  should she get that title? She's not my personal favorite but I give credit where credit is due. If not Sarah who do you guys/girls think qualifies as G.O.A.T material?

[sinclairfan]

Ariel X
Holly Holm
Sugar Ray Renee

[jaybee]

Ariel X
Holly Holm
Sugar Ray Renee

-Ariel X is DEFINITELY worthy to be given consideration as GOAT!
-Sugar Ray Renee?... she's good and had a long career but I don't think her resume is versatile enough to categorize her as GOAT. Hall of fame?... DEFINITELY, but not GOAT (IMO)
-As far as Holly Holmes goes DEFINITELY a fight legend but I'm talking about the catfight/fantasy fight business only.

[caryn1]

blake mitchell might make the list also

[DoubleT2]

If we’re talking fantasy catfighters then the list will likely be long and distinguished due to the unique tastes of all on this site. I’ve always enjoyed Goldie Blair, who puts on both realistic (vs Fiona) and sexy (vs Christina) scraps. Tammy prefers Renee from CatfightHaven for similar reasons. Tim

[jaybee]

To narrow down the selections I'll add the guide lines that to qualify as GOAT you have to have performed for numerous companies and preformed in different genres of catfighting ex. Real catfights/wrestling (ECNWC type, competitive wrestling , or even pro-wrestling), fantasy/scripted, bonus points for WAM wrestling. Performing in all the above is a REAL +, also years active, and popularity.

[LQQKING4CATFIGHTER]

  Nadege, Veve, Raquel from Seattle, Kathy Gifford

[lumberjack66]

I gotta say Sugar Ray Renee.  She was so tough they used to make her fight up one weight class just to make it fair.

[LQQKING4CATFIGHTER]

I gotta say Sugar Ray Renee.  She was so tough they used to make her fight up one weight class just to make it fair.

   The only 80's LA Catfight Model I'd maybe name would be Robin. All the other girls did 90% scripted matches. Renee did some real competitive matches but most was scripted.

[Bunpbner-man-22]

There’s several imo.  There’s not one top.

Lisa-Marie is probably the first one who pops into my mind. 

Sarah Brooke is probably the current GOAT

Ariel X is probably the GOAT of the past Decade

Francesca Le is probably the GOAT of scripted fights

Tina/Robin are probably two GOATs who are in the smaller weight category

For me Lisa-Marie is probably the greatest imo.  She was literally a pioneer across all of the genre.  I’m not sure though how she’d fair in a ECNWC type match that we see today but I’m pretty sure she would still wreck house if she was in her prime like the other women.

[phftfghtr]

  ... Veve...

Veve... The best pantyhose catfights ever!

[jaybee]

There’s several imo.  There’s not one top.

Lisa-Marie is probably the first one who pops into my mind. 

Sarah Brooke is probably the current GOAT

Ariel X is probably the GOAT of the past Decade

Francesca Le is probably the GOAT of scripted fights

Tina/Robin are probably two GOATs who are in the smaller weight category

For me Lisa-Marie is probably the greatest imo.  She was literally a pioneer across all of the genre.  I’m not sure though how she’d fair in a ECNWC type match that we see today but I’m pretty sure she would still wreck house if she was in her prime like the other women.

Lisa-Marie?... The tall redhead Aussie(?) from back in the day? If we're talking about the same woman I was in LOVE with her! She fought for so many companies calisupreme, DT, TPC. She even did a few scripted clothes ripping catfights for Crystalfilms! Too bad she didn't do all out real catfights but she did a lot of competitive wrestling around the globe.

[jon222]

Kelli Wildcat won every fight she ever did except against a blonde one time

Agree Lisa Marie destroyed her opponents and only lost a few times. Gorgeous as well

Robin who mostly did Joan wise beat every woman she ever faced except for a muscular blonde

I think Alexa Brooke who recently retired was amazing but not a goat

Fighting dolls mariles is a thick blonde who wrecks nearly all her opponents

[jaybee]

Kelli Wildcat won every fight she ever did except against a blonde one time

Agree Lisa Marie destroyed her opponents and only lost a few times. Gorgeous as well

Robin who mostly did Joan wise beat every woman she ever faced except for a muscular blonde

I think Alexa Brooke who recently retired was amazing but not a goat

Fighting dolls mariles is a thick blonde who wrecks nearly all her opponents

WAIT WAIT WAIT.... HOLD UP!!
Alexa Brooke... the girl who fought for Suitfights and just recently Tilly has retired ALREADY!? She was becoming a big deal, what happened? Why the quick exit?

[Mikebt]

I would love to see Sarah Brooke take on Kim-ly from fighting dolls. That would be a real title fight.

As much as I love Sarah, I think Kim-Ly would be out of her league. Those girls at fighting dolls are ripped and on another level, especially Kim-Ly and Andy. I'll say this though... would love to see them in a real anything goes catfight where they couldn't rely just on wrestling skills.

To me the best international opponent for Sarah would be Pandora from Catz Review. Both girls are smoking hot and Pandora can absolutely slap with the best of them. Her ground game is also good so her and Sarah would be an absolute blast.

Back to the topic, I'd like to mention Treena Collins and Nancy Novak as well. They were amazing back in the 80s. Treena even had one ECNWC fight where she took down the undefeated Heidi.