Here’s my two cents worth. This is how I imagine my dream catfight.
Nude fights appear contrived, regardless how real they are. Clothed catfights (without stripping) can seem more spontaneous and natural. I’d love to see two girls fighting who are dressed similarly, with jeans tucked into calf-length leather boots, and wide leather belts. Or maybe in uniform, different or same, e.g., nurse vs cop, or nurse vs nurse etc. to name a couple of possible combinations. All I want to see grabbed is hair, lots of it, and constantly. Nudity is out for me.
Whatever delivers the EXACT specific action and outcome I want is fine by me. I’m okay with scripted but I’d need it to be realistic. Girls pretending that they’re serious enemies may work out well if they are convincing enough. A genuine fight leaves no room for doubt. A hybrid of a real fight, with some fantasy roleplay, would be the best of both worlds. A backstory giving a reason for the fight makes it more authentic and believable. Something with a straightforward good girl vs bad girl scenario.
I like unfair one-sided fights, with a large side serving of injustice. The more injustice the better! Two mismatched girls could show that inequality. One girl would need to be brave enough to go into it knowing she faces almost certain domination. It may not 100% guarantee the pre-decided result I’d want to see but it should help to tip the scales in the right direction. Even better if the girl I want to get the worst of it does appear afraid for real and reluctant to fight. I love the idea of one girl who expects to lose being somehow coerced into it, against her will. Or just attacked without warning.
I don’t like slapping. Never have, never will. Many do but I just really don’t, so it’s out for me. I don’t know exactly why, but I’m not a fan. It’s hairpulling and rolling around I like. Better athletic ability comes from one woman continuously mounting her opponent and pinning/crushing her beneath her. Combine that with viciously yanking her hair, and it’s orgasmic! There’s nothing more disrespectful than one woman attacking the crowning glory of her rival by tearing it mercilessly. It shows enough personal hatred for me. The girl who has been mounted and is being dominated also pulls hair in desperation. And frustration.
Trailer trash is a no-go, and for the same reasons. I’m not interested in any vulnerable women being forced to have a bad experience just for being down on their luck. Life is bad enough without adding to anyone’s misery. Needs to be two attractive girls who are both willing to fight. Ideally in the range of nineteen years old to mid-thirties.
Sexuality is irrelevant as ‘sex-fights’ and ‘trib-fights’ don’t interest me. I’m okay with bi-sexual chicks or lesbians but my fantasy has them fighting over me so they would be straight.